Hi hogi, that did the trick; thank you. Half the battle for us newbies is knowing what a plot is called (didn't know it was a "vector plot"). Using your info I was able to reproduce the plot in my original post using JMP:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a523d/a523dc65dff05aba2590c116a86f74b6356893c1" alt="JPB_3-1706201650167.png JPB_3-1706201650167.png"
For those who are interested, I have attached a second file with the script for this plot included. Run the script "Vector Plot", right click on the chart and select "Customize..." from the drop-down menu, select "Script" and you'll see what I had to add to make the arrows appear, namely:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fecdf/fecdf5af87f93fdb2d19372e1431d1ccadfd0478" alt="JPB_4-1706201912660.png JPB_4-1706201912660.png"
Note that the first time I did this there was no Script option, so I pressed the "+" button, which made it appear. After making the addition I pressed OK and voila: the desired arrows.