cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Discussions

Solve problems, and share tips and tricks with other JMP users.
Choose Language Hide Translation Bar
Upa_Upitas
Level I

How to compare the results between two DoE/Response Surfaces?

Hey, 

I have been characterizing different reactors using DoE to establish the correlation/equation between identical one response y and two independent parameters x1, x2. The DoE and data analysis for each reactor were not designed with JMP but in Python. 

 

Now, I would like to get the correlation on one reactor and compare statistically the correlation with other, assessing differences and similarities..., with JMP. I though on overlapping the surfaces plots, for instance, but would like to explore JMP capabilities. The Python generated the tables for each reactor on x1, x2 & y. I couldn´t find any tutorial to develop such a comparison given that the DoE wasn´t initially designed in JMP. I have the results directly. 

How could I input the data into JMP and perform the comparison?  

Thank you

1 REPLY 1
P_Bartell
Level VIII

Re: How to compare the results between two DoE/Response Surfaces?

Let's start with how the response data was actually collected because in large measure this will help determine the suggested analysis pathways. Was the data collected in the context of a designed experiment? You cited using Python rather than JMP to design the experiment. Not sure what that means. How was 'reactor' treated as a factor type in the design, if treated at all? Outright classification factor unto itself? Or a blocking factor? What other nuisance variables might be in play between the reactors? For example, were the same raw materials used in each reactor? We used to run experiments on a 'reactor' half a world away from the other, with the idea of trying to compare the 'reactor' effect...and there was no way we had identical raw materials, let alone, operators, measurement systems and on and on.

Was the data 'happenstance data'? In other words, did you just collect manufacturing data from multiple process runs and are now trying to torture information/insight out of it? Commonplace in manufacturing data...hey, the data is almost 'free'! We might as well try and see what we can see!

All these issues will lead to selection of appropriate analysis pathways. But regardless of the answers to the above questions...my advice wrt to analysis is start with simple visualizations of the data that help answer the practical questions at hand. There is always the temptation to jump right to modeling of some sort and ignoring/skipping over JMP's more simple visualization platforms like Graph Builder, Distribution, and Fit Y by X.

Last 'ask'...can you share your data set...even if it's anonymized? 

Recommended Articles