Graph builder problem with lines, markers, and dots

[#1]

Hi All,

I am submitting this again because the response I initially accepted didn't actually solve the problem. My problem is that when I create a graph in graph builder with continuous data in the Y and the X axis, and use one categorical in the Overlay, I get continuous lines. But as soon as I put a second categorical in "Color," the lines change to dotted, etc even though the line style shows an uninterrupted line. This didn't use to happen, and I don't know why it is happening now. I tried changing the Overlay encoding to color but while that gives me continuous lines, it changes the markers to identical dots.

I am attaching a sample file from the JMP help index to which I saved the script for a couple of graphs that show what I mean.

Any help with this issue is much appreciated!

Barbara

[#2]

Hi Barbara, 

What you are describing sounds like the correct function to me. The Overlay Variable encodes the Style of the Lines and Markers. Could you clarify what your desired result is? Thank you for including the sample dataset; could you give a bit more context about what the example graphs are aiming to communicate? 

If you do not wanted dotted lines: have you tried setting overlay encoding to None? Now only the Color variable will affect the appearance of the lines and markers. 

If your concern is that the legend doesn't match the graph: you can edit the legend to show the missing dotted line entries by double-clicking on the legend. 

[#3]

link to previous post: Graph Builder Problem with Lines 

Overlay encoding:

[#4]

Hi Christian,

I also submitted this problem to JMP support. I turns out that under Preferences - Platforms - Graph Builder, I had to set the Overlay Auto Line Style Limit to 1. If I run into this problem again or find that this setting causes other problems, I will try setting the Overlay Encoding to None.

Thanks,

Barbara

[#5]

Thanks @babn  & JMP support for this super cool trick.

Nevertheless:
Please be aware that it's dangerous to change settings in the preferences!
If several colleagues in a company use JMP, or if you install JMP on more than one computer you will run into unexpected issues:
Do you use the preferences? 

To avoid different plots on different computers, everyone/every computer in the company must (!) share the same settings in the preferences.

[#6]

On the other hand:
Overlay with same line style : sounds familiar - here  are some related topics:

•  "jump-back-lines" in line plots - and the wish for an easy option to remove them: possibility to add breaks 
  -> issue will be fixed in a future version of JMP:
  https://community.jmp.com/t5/JMP-Wish-List/Graph-Builder-Line-possibility-to-add-breaks/idc-p/921029... 
  
  
  
• Do you know how to generate this graph in Graph Builder?
  it looks so innocent! Very surprising how complicated it is to create the plot in Graph Builder!
  If it's your Job to create such plots, you wish there was an  easier way -  some consistent marker control in Graph Builder 
  
  
  

And a bit off-topic:

• Why is it not possible to generate this graph in JMP?