cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
The Discovery Summit 2025 Call for Content is open! Submit an abstract today to present at our premier analytics conference.
See how to use JMP Live to centralize and share reports within groups. Webinar with Q&A April 4, 2pm ET.
Choose Language Hide Translation Bar
View Original Published Thread

DOE constrain not working

eldad_galili
Level III

Hi All,

 

I have JMP 16, and I want to design a DOE with the attached factors and the below constrains.

When I get the stage of the design test it ignor the constrain, without any warning messege.

Can anybody help me with this?

 

Suplier == "Finland" & ("\!"Nazal\!" Amount"n == "160" | "\!"Nazal\!" Amount"n ==
"180") & ("\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "80-20" |
"\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "60-40" | "\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n ==
"50-50") & (Unraveling time == "105" | Unraveling time == "120") & (
Sealing material percentage == "0.5" | Sealing material percentage == "1" |
Sealing material percentage == "1.5")

 

Thanks,

Eldad

 

 

2 ACCEPTED SOLUTIONS

Accepted Solutions
Phil_Kay
Staff


Re: DOE constrain not working

I suspect that it is the way that you have defined your disallowed combinations with ANDs between all the conditions. I don't think that it is defining the disallowed combinations that you intended.

 

I have broken out the conditions that you have linked with ANDs into separate lines to try and make more sense of it:

 

Suplier == "Finland" 
& ("\!"Nazal\!" Amount"n == "160" | "\!"Nazal\!" Amount"n =="180") 
& ("\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "80-20" | "\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "60-40" | "\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "50-50") 
& (Unraveling time == "105" | Unraveling time == "120") 
& (Sealing material percentage == "0.5" | Sealing material percentage == "1" | Sealing material percentage == "1.5")

 

 

Perhaps this way of defining the disallowed combinations works better:

 

(Suplier == "Finland" 
& ("\!"Nazal\!" Amount"n == "160" | "\!"Nazal\!" Amount"n =="180"))
|
(Suplier == "Finland"
& ("\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "80-20" | "\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "60-40" | "\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "50-50"))
|
(Suplier == "Finland"
& (Unraveling time == "105" | Unraveling time == "120"))
|
(Suplier == "Finland"
& (Sealing material percentage == "0.5" | Sealing material percentage == "1" | Sealing material percentage == "1.5"))

Here each condition is separated with an OR.

See the attached Custom Design that was created with these disallowed combinations.

I would have some concerns about how useful this experiment is because most combinations are disallowed when Suplier = Finland. But again, maybe that is not what you intended.

It might help if you can state in words the nature of the disallowed combinations that you have in your experiment.

I hope this helps,
Phil

 

 

View solution in original post

eldad_galili
Level III

Re: DOE constrain not working

Thank yoy very much, your suggestion of changing between "and" to "or" worked!!

View solution in original post

2 REPLIES 2
Phil_Kay
Staff


Re: DOE constrain not working

I suspect that it is the way that you have defined your disallowed combinations with ANDs between all the conditions. I don't think that it is defining the disallowed combinations that you intended.

 

I have broken out the conditions that you have linked with ANDs into separate lines to try and make more sense of it:

 

Suplier == "Finland" 
& ("\!"Nazal\!" Amount"n == "160" | "\!"Nazal\!" Amount"n =="180") 
& ("\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "80-20" | "\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "60-40" | "\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "50-50") 
& (Unraveling time == "105" | Unraveling time == "120") 
& (Sealing material percentage == "0.5" | Sealing material percentage == "1" | Sealing material percentage == "1.5")

 

 

Perhaps this way of defining the disallowed combinations works better:

 

(Suplier == "Finland" 
& ("\!"Nazal\!" Amount"n == "160" | "\!"Nazal\!" Amount"n =="180"))
|
(Suplier == "Finland"
& ("\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "80-20" | "\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "60-40" | "\!"Long-Short\!" fiber ratio"n == "50-50"))
|
(Suplier == "Finland"
& (Unraveling time == "105" | Unraveling time == "120"))
|
(Suplier == "Finland"
& (Sealing material percentage == "0.5" | Sealing material percentage == "1" | Sealing material percentage == "1.5"))

Here each condition is separated with an OR.

See the attached Custom Design that was created with these disallowed combinations.

I would have some concerns about how useful this experiment is because most combinations are disallowed when Suplier = Finland. But again, maybe that is not what you intended.

It might help if you can state in words the nature of the disallowed combinations that you have in your experiment.

I hope this helps,
Phil

 

 

eldad_galili
Level III

Re: DOE constrain not working

Thank yoy very much, your suggestion of changing between "and" to "or" worked!!