cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
  • Sign-in to the JMP Community will be unavailable intermittently Dec. 6-7 due to a system update. Thank you for your understanding!
  • We’re retiring the File Exchange at the end of this year. The JMP Marketplace is now your destination for add-ins and extensions.
  • JMP 19 is here! Learn more about the new features.

Discussions

Solve problems, and share tips and tricks with other JMP users.
Choose Language Hide Translation Bar
Jonkandonkan
Level III

Repeated measures ANOVA - Within group

I want to do simple 1-Way RM-ANOVA. One group, three timepoints. Is there a difference between the timepoints. Only interested in effect of Time and then pairwise comparisons (Tukey). It's a cross-over design with three different exposures. 

Is it adequate to do this in the Fit Y by X platform? The response variable of interest on Y, and "Time" (session in my case)) on X? I prefer this way making it easy to do post-hoc test directly in the same platform.

 

Here I can also fit BY group. While there are two groups in the project I primarily want to analyse these separately (one model for one group, one for the other, not interested in the interaction here, while it might be a secondary analysis). 

 

I.e. 

Jonkandonkan_0-1713860254046.png

 

 

However, it can also be done in the Fit Model approach. In the MANOVA approach, I would just put the three time points on Y and nothing in the model effect (potentially BY group). This seems to have higher power. Is this adequate? 

Jonkandonkan_2-1713860344924.png

 


In the Fit model univariate approach, I would put the response variable as Y and "Time" aswell as subject[Random effect] in the model effect? This seems seems to have even slighly higher power (smaller P for same data). 

Jonkandonkan_1-1713860302449.png

 (And potentially by group)

 

What's the practical/statistical difference for these approaches? Which is most adequate, for this quite simple design? 

3 REPLIES 3
Jonkandonkan
Level III

Re: Repeated measures ANOVA - Within group

Perhaps, In the Fit Y by X it is not treated as a repeated measure but three separate groups. 

Jonkandonkan
Level III

Re: Repeated measures ANOVA - Within group

Or perhaps, this the way to do it, not puting ID as a random factor, and keeping the Least Squares personality?

Which gives the effect tests for Time, and giving the possibility for Tukeys and similar contrasts.

 

Jonkandonkan_1-1713862208095.png

 

 

 

 

Jonkandonkan
Level III

Re: Repeated measures ANOVA - Within group

I guess this I want to do, as Paris in the video of One factor repeatead measures analysis.

 

Jonkandonkan_0-1713862863860.png

 

Recommended Articles