I'm missing something here... the two pictures appear to give the same results, just with a different scale on the y-axis of the profiler. One of them goes from 0 to 10-ish and the other goes from 0 to 20-ish. The response output and confidence interval are identical. Can you help with a little more detail about with difference you are seeing?
I'm guessing you inadvertently adjusted the Y-axis range.
Hope this helps.